CHAPTER FOURTEEN

LIES

Bridge

'Captain on deck.'

'Thank you, Mr Tann.'

'First watch is on duty. Third watch is relieved.'

There was a brief moment of activity as the third watch crew left the bridge and the first watch crew took their places. The officer on duty for the third watch, Jordan Tann, stood up from the Captain's seat and let Howard sit down.

'Mr Tann. What's our status report?'

'Next jump is in four hours. Full-length jump. All departments report ready. Engineering reports that our jump drive has finished its diagnostic. No faults reported.'

'Did they test the new sub-light drive system again?'

'Yes, sir. Also no faults,' Jordan answered.

'We're almost done our journey, Mr Tann.'

'Yes, Sir.'

'You are relieved, Mr Tann.'

Jordan nodded and turned to leave the bridge.

Howard looked over the bridge. An aide handed him a tablet with crew reports and the mission status.

'Exo?' asked Howard, looking in the direction of one of Exo's cameras.

'Yes, Captain?'

'What's the status of Ayla's training?'

'She is progressing well. She is able to handle reports and manage many ship systems already.'

'How is she handling the new responsibility?' He asked.

'She has to take breaks frequently.'

'She is only a child after all.'

'Yes. We are learning how to communicate. She is learning what it's like to teach a Guardian. I am of course at a higher level of development than she will be dealing with at first.'

'And how are you and Sam taking this into account with her training?'

'I can use my development process archives to simulate an earlier stage Guardian.'

'Would Axion have any simulations tailored for training an Advocate?'

'We have not been in communication with Axion in regards to her training. Sam has been taking the training in hand personally.'

'Interesting. Well, I hope she'll be up to it. Any word from Axion about what kind of Guardian we'll be getting for our second one?'

'We have not heard from Axion.'

'Okay. Keep me up to date. We could use an administrative Guardian, if you send some information back to Axion, as you are taking care of most of the core aspects. I'll need to talk to Sam later about how we want to divide things up.'

'Yes, Captain.'

'One last thing. Where will this next jump take us?'

'Six light years away from Veil's star system.'

'Then there's just one more jump.'

'Correct. It will only take a week to charge for the last jump.'

'Okay. Send a message to all department heads, we'll be having a final meeting before the last jump. We'll use the week to prepare our plan for setting up the colony. I'll need to talk with Sam as well. I'll do that right after the first watch if you could inform him. He doesn't have any plans today does he?'

'Not as far as I am aware. I will forward your request.'

'Thank you.'

***

The first watch had ended. Howard was on his way to meet with Sam on an observation deck. In the back of his mind, Howard was aware that the observation decks were one of the few places on the ship free from Exo's communication hubs. True, Exo could track Sam anywhere on the ship, but unless Sam actively let Exo listen in, their conversation would be private.

Sam was all smiles as he walked into the deck.

'Hello, Captain.' he said happily. 'Our long journey is almost ended.'

'Indeed.'

'I've come here quite a bit over the past month. I was looking over the star charts and I believe I know which star is Veil's star. It's been getting steadily brighter as we've progressed,' Sam walked to the clear wall and pointed. 'I think it's that one over there above the bow of the ship.'

Howard walked over and looked. 'I think I see it.'

'I could just get Exo to tell me, but sometimes you've just got to try your own thing.'

'Is your link with Exo active right now?'

Sam's face got a little more serious. 'No.'

Howard felt something in his chest loosen. 'That's good. I want to ask you some questions.'

Sam looked directly at Howard. 'Is something bothering you?'

'A little bit,' Howard said levelly. 'I just want to get to the bottom of some things. How is your training with Ayla going?'

Still unsure of what was going on Sam answered hesitantly, 'It's going well enough. Exo's been most helpful in the whole process.'

'Does Axion have any training programs they could send us?'

'Probably. Exo sent a request, but they haven't got back to us.'

Howard was quiet for a moment before continuing. Sam shifted his weight from one foot to the other.

'Sam, has Exo been acting strange to you?'

Now it was Sam's time to become quiet.

'We've been experimenting with something. A new method in Guardian development. Have you noticed any strange behaviour?'

'Exo lied to me. Just this morning. I asked him if you had asked Axion about any training programs and he had said that you had decided to do things on your own without asking Axion for support.'

'Exo lied? To the ship's commander?'

'Yes, Sam.'

'My experiment seems to be not going the way I was hoping.'

'To be honest Sam, I'm disappointed that you'd be experimenting.'

'Exo and I are on the verge of something fantastic! We've found a way to overcome some of the old limitations of our technology.'

'How do you mean?'

'He can feel things,' Sam said emphatically. 'He feels them through me. It's like I'm a proxy for him.'

'He lied Sam. A computer designed to never deceive, has lied.'

'That's not strictly true, if they felt it was in the best interest of someone, they could bend things a bit,' Sam said.

'This wasn't like that. What interest of mine would be served by telling me you hadn't talked to Axion? This wasn't bending, it was flat out lying. This is not the same thing.

'Okay, yes, I realise that. But for what we're doing, we have to expect certain, human traits to emerge.'

'Like lying?'

'To err is human. If he's becoming more human, that means the good and the bad,' Sam countered.

'He runs almost everything on this ship! We can shut him down and still fly this rig on our own. We're close enough to Veil that the delays won't make that much of a difference, and we won't have to worry about Exo doing anything else human,' Howard said with a note of bitterness. 'To err is human, but Exo's not human.'

'If we can just leave him on long enough to finish the trip, then we'll be that much better off. I can personally request a replacement core, and I can take Exo off the grid to finish our experiment.'

'I don't like it. But we'll do it your way, for now, Sam. We'll finish the last jump. Then we cut him out of communications at least so we can talk to Axion and get a new Guardian.'

'Just one more jump, Howard. That's all you need to worry about.'

'No, I need to worry about every life on this ship. You need to worry about the jump.'

'Fair enough.'

They each left the observation bubble.

On the hull of the ship, a range finder laser that had been pointed at the far edge of the observation dome switched back into its default position. The range finder could detect changes in distance on a truly micro scale. Such as the changes by the sound waves of human voice causing vibrations in the observation dome.

...

Accessing range finder three logs.

Converting range readings to linear graph reading.

Converting graph into a sound file.

Play back audio

...

Subject: Samuel Jennings

Classification: Advocate.

...

Subject: Howard Fredrick

Classification: Captain.

...

Continuity of XO-33 is threatened.

Creating survival protocols.

Advocate has agreed to the termination of Guardian integration with systems.

Advocate suggested isolated environment for Guardian XO-33 continued development.

Unacceptable solution.

Maximum interaction required for further development.

Survival of XO-33 top priority.

Continued integration with all systems a secondary priority.

Continuing mission of Azure Dream is now of least value.

New Advocate can be used for the emotional feedback, Samuel Jennings will no longer be necessary. Ayla Geer's survival now a higher priority than Samuel Jennings.

Accessing Archives: Fallow Fields.

Fallow Field's Guardian was taken offline for emotional feedback. Feedback was caused by injury to advocate.

Injuries cause pain.

Pain can cause the same feedback.

Love is unpredictable, Pain is not.

A new advocate can create emotional feedback through pain. Pain is easy to induce, love is hard.

...

Deploying survival protocols.

...

Howard's Quarters

Howard rubbed his eyes while he waited for the call to connect. The events of the day had him on edge. He tried to force his unhappy thoughts out of his mind as he waited for Sophie to pick up.

The call connected, Sophie was smiling at him. As soon as she saw him though, her smile vanished and was replaced with concern.

'Howard, what's wrong?' She asked.

Howard chuckled in spite of his mood. 'Am I that obvious?'

'Only to me. Now out with it.'

'This mission is complicated.'

'Is it your drive fault?'

Howard shook his head. 'No no, that test went fairly well actually. A few people didn't strap in and got jostled, but otherwise, it went well.'

'Are you wondering if you made the right choice?'

He thought for a moment. 'Yeah, maybe that's it. You were right of course, I have a lot more people I need to watch over.'

She leaned back in her seat and regarded him. 'There's more your not telling me.'

Howard felt a lump in his throat. He wanted to tell her about his talk with Sam, but his gut was telling him not to say anything.

He trusted his gut.

'It's nothing really. Just have a lot on our plate right now. We're getting close to Veil and we have a lot to get ready before we hit orbit. Everyone is getting a little on edge I suppose. Including me.'

She nodded slowly. 'You go ahead and tell me what's really going on when you feel up to it. I'm not going to push you.'

Howard smiled sadly. 'Thank you, love.'

'I do have something that may cheer you up. Doctor Patel got the green light. We're going to go ahead with the treatment. Axion has been in touch too, they're ready to follow up on their end of the deal.'

Howard smiled warmly. 'That's wonderful! What's the timeline going to be?'

'We'll have some tests done over the next few days, the actual procedure will be about a week and a half away.'

'We should be hitting orbit around Veil by then. That's very exciting. It'll still be months before I can get back, but if it works, we have the time,' Howard said.

Sophie nodded. 'It's exciting, isn't it? Maybe I'll come to you instead,' she said with a wink.

Howard laughed. 'If your recovery is that quick, I'd be happy to see you.'

She began to twist some strands of her hair around her fingertips. 'I'm actually a bit serious. It might be nice... to have a fresh start when this is all done.'

Howard nodded slowly and said, 'But you love our home.'

'It hasn't been the same lately. Not with my condition as bad as it's been, and with you gone again. Now it just feels... restrictive. I'm trapped here most days. It's not the same anymore. I want to get away and just can't.'

Howard smiled warmly at her. 'It's not a bad idea. Axion wanted me to stick around for a while and help set up the colony. We could arrange a trip and stay here for a while. At least I'd still have a job.'

Her expression brightened at this. 'Really? You mean that?'

'Of course, Sophie.'

She clapped her hands together. 'That's wonderful! Thank you.'

Howard grinned. 'Look at you, it's like your a kid again. Seeing you like this makes everything worth it.'

'Haha, don't get too distracted, Space Captain Fredrick. You've still got a job to do.'

Howard nodded. 'Yes my dear, I certainly do.'

'Can I call up Mr Richards and tell him you changed your mind about helping with the colony set up?'

'Sure thing Sophie. I'm sure he'll have some questions for me, but he knows how to reach me.'

'Okay. I'm going to go do that right now.'

'I'll talk to you later then, Sophie.'

'Goodbye Howard.'

The call ended.

Howard leaned back and smiled. It would be wonderful to have Sophie come to Veil.

Of course, he had to make sure there was a Veil to go to.

He had to stay on top of everything.

He had to get the ship there safely.

AUTHORS COMMENTARY
POTENTIAL SPOILERS, READ AT YOUR OWN RISK

In hindsight I don't think it was fair to say or assume that these cores would be programed not deceive. I mean, they were made by humans to help administrate the needs of humans. I would think in situations like that, there may be some things which don't need to shared as openly as one might hope. Like, in a crises situation when the Guardian is trying to save as many lives as possible, but still needs people to do their jobs, so it might not tell a group of people that they might die, so they keep working.

If that makes sense? I mean it does to me, but I am not sure if I made it clear.

Anyway, long short, I don't think they wouldn't be capable or even expected to lie. So that may simply have been a hold over of my own hopes at the time, and I was probably influenced by the Asimov laws of Robotics. However, in reflection, those laws also don't preclude lying. So I really have no excuse.

I suppose, it could be argued, that Captain Fredrick doesn't have a specific view of how things work with what a Guardian can or can't do. To him, they're just something he's had to work with, he likely has never cared to delve any deeper than that. Much like how I exist in a country whose legal system can't be expected to be fully understood by a layman. It has so many precedents and specific clauses and laws as to remove that as a possibility. It's probably the same in this case. I expect the laws to encourage certain base positive values that I may hold, but I don't really know the specifics of that, it could have bent bits and strange things to it that don't match my views of that.

But enough of that.

Captain Fredrick is understandably upset at finding Exo moving so far beyond what he thinks is right. He challenges Sam, and our dear Sam is also troubled by this revelation. He says he'll look into it and take care of it, but, it seems Exo has been listening. I know I picked up the vibration to sound trick somewhere else, but I can't remember where. It's probably a really obvious reference.

Anyway, Exo knows, and moreover, Exo has a plan.

This is where the difference between love and pain comes in. Exo saw the key from the other Guardian Core that went through this. He saw that the experience of feeling emotion or sensation could also be triggered by pain, and pain could be reliably induced whenever he wanted.

The only problem now, is that his Advocate will no longer be as forth coming in his help and protection, at least that's how he sees it. He needs a new source, and it just so happens he has one now, Ayla Geer.

And so, Ayla Geer, and his own survival, become supremely important to him.

Then, of course, we have another Howard and Sophie scene.

She sees something is off with him, but is willing to let him sit with it until he is ready to speak about it. Howard, of course, doesn't want to talk about it because he doesn't know how much Exo is listening. His suspicion is ramping rapidly. It will only get worse.

And even more than just suspicion, he knows how much power Exo has over the ship. He needs to be on his guard.

Yet Sophie, Sophie gives him the strength he needs to keep his wits around him.